The Song of Sourwood Mountain by Ann H. Gabhart

 

Ann Gabhart is best known for her sweet romances set in the early 20th century Appalachians. I've been following her stories for awhile now and I know I can count on Gabhart to always have a close attention to detail and a wonderfully vivid, detail filled capturing of the Appalachian spirit and the traditions and personalities of those who lived in the communities there.

Once again I loved Gabhart's choice of setting. Sourwood was delightful to explore, especially through Mira's fresh eyes and Ada June's enthusiasm. Gabhart also tried to give a balance to the community from the sweet young Joseph to the distant Riley. As someone who grew up in a rural community I appreciate when a fictional community shows the same sort of quirks that make those communities home.

That said, these may be my least favourite of Gabhart's main characters. Mira is a sweet and brave young woman but I struggled with the way her relationship with Gordon was presented. The entire "God told me to pursue you" and continuing to pursue until they were married a week later is such a dangerous mentality that has been romanticized to the harm of many women. I feel like I would have enjoyed Mira and Gordon so much more if they had a recent history or a longer courtship instead of their red flag start and Gordon's continual refusal to communicate throughout the book.

Ada June's story on the other hand left me wanting more. I would have easily read a book solely devoted to her story of finding herself and her family. I loved how Gabhart paced her healing, I loved the respect given to her trauma induced mutism, and she had such a spirit about her. However, because it was Mira's story not Ada June's I found myself more invested in Ada June without the same level of resolution.

While Mira's story does follow the traditional pattern of a happy ending in this genre, Ada June's as a secondary character felt like it had loose threads. Still readable but less satisfying.

3 out of 5 stars.

I received a copy of this book as part of the RevellReads program in exchange for my honest opinion. 

The Irish Matchmaker by Jennifer Deibel

 

Jennifer Deibel is back with another February release! 

The Irish Matchmaker is Deibel's fourth release and are her novels are becoming a midwinter tradition around here. I don't know about you but after a few months of Canadian winter I need something cozy, sweet, and delivers an ending that leaves me smiling and this tale fit the bill entirely.

This time Deibel invites readers into the lives of Donal Bunratty, a farmer and single father to nine year old Sara, and Catriona Daly one of the matchmakers of Lisdoovarna.

I loved these characters and the care with which Deibel crafts their story. While this definitely is a romance, Deibel made sure to give each character their own foundation to stand on. Caty's search for self and security and Donal's search for wholeness after the losses in his life provided a rich setting for the romance to bloom amid the Lisdoovarna Matchmaking festival (which does actually exist to this day). 

While A Dance in Donegal is still my favourite overall tale from Deibel, Caty and Donal are my favourite romance. Deibel's pacing in this story was delightful. The romance happens naturally allowing for so many sweet scenes (I still can't decide if the painting scene or the dance was my favourite). This more natural pacing also crossed over into the religious elements. Donal's journey through his hurt and grief, his slow return to his faith, and his eventual return to community felt relatable in that it honours his pain while still providing the hopeful conclusion you expect in the genre.

As usual, Deibel provides wonderful worldbuilding through her descriptions of the Irish countryside, the festivities surrounding the festival, and the use of Irish words throughout the story (I recommend a second bookmark for the glossary at the front).

4.5/5 stars

I received a copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion, the views expressed are my own.